Columbia Faith & Values

Blogs » Yossi Feintuch - Lessons from the Torah

Instruction on meat

This week in synagogues worldwide, the annual cycle of Torah public reading is renewed, with Simhat Torah (Rejoicing in Torah), the last festival of the Fall holy days that marks both the conclusion of the cycle and its prompt renewal with the book of Genesis.

There in the terse narration of creation (that resembles the process of evolution as willed by God) the first earthlings are charged with “hold[ing] sway over” the earth’s fauna (Genesis 1:28), but that does not mean that humans are entitled to eat the flesh of animals or even their by-products. Indeed, the Creator prescribes a pure vegan regimen to all the living creatures beginning with humans (Gen. 1:29-30) which He repeats again: “From every fruit of the garden you may surely eat” (2:16).

Ten generations later, God similarly instructs Noah to stock and store such food on his ark to sustain all of its travelers (Gen. 6:21) for the duration of the forthcoming flood and its immediate aftermath. To be sure, even if meat had been permitted it could not have been kept in an edible form to say the least throughout that period.

Only upon disembarkation does God permits Noah (and humankind) to consume meat, just “like the green plants” (9:3), however, sans the animal’s blood. Or in other words, meat may now be added to the human diet but without blood in it, meaning also that humane slaughtering – the Kosher method -- was required to avoid cutting into the animal with “its lifeblood still in it” (9:4), a biblical requisite that the meat industry today falls way short of meeting. 

Still, the very consumption of meat is in and by itself a testament to a world that is not redeemed, yet to reclaim its perfection. When the prophet Isaiah describes the eating regimen of creation’s fauna in a perfected world it is clear that all living creatures revert “back to the future” when even both “the cow and the bear shall graze… and the lion shall eat straw like the ox” (Isaiah 11:7).

Topics: Faith, Doctrine & Practice
Beliefs: Judaism
Tags: creation, meat, noah, simhat torah, torah

Comments

  1. The New York Times Magazine ran a contest recently, asking writers to give reasons in support of eating meat. Most of us had a hard time justifying our meat-eating habits. But to tell the truth, I found anything short of fruitarianism (which is more stringent than veganism) to be questionable ethically.

    Here’s my argument for eating meat, such as it is:
    http://barbarafalconernewhall.com/?s=ok+sorta

  2. Thank you for your sharing.  I ‘d love to hear your reflection after you viewed Gary Yourofsky 2010 talk at GA Tech, a lecture requiring some 70 minutes to watch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=es6U00LMmC4

Add Your Comment

The colour of a red ant is?

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter